SEPHORA COLLECTION Retractable Waterproof Eyeliner 09 Glitter Black

I had to stock up these while i can get my hands for affordable price. After tons of eye liners I've ever used for decades, this is my favorite eye liner with touch of silver glitter. I am completely sold on these and dodged Dior, Clinique, Lancom, Smashbox, Ready to wear, Mally and all the rest. It does smudge a bit but it is no terrible and it never irritates my eyes. It is soft enough to smoothly glides around your eye areas but it never breaks off or never had the retractable enclosure malfunctioned on me. You can use this till it is actually GONE out. I just hope the Sephora will NEVER discontinue this product! Please !!

This is my favorite eyeliner!!! It stays on all day, doesn't run under my eye, and is glitery. I have it in several colors, and LOVE!

easy to use and stay on

I was looking for a glittery eyeliner to replace my Milani ones, which I couldn't find at Target anymore. Is it waterproof? I don't know since I did not get rained on with these on, nor did I go swimming in it. I do know it lasts all day under normal weather conditions. It's easy to apply on. But then I don't apply in a very thin line, which I think might be a little hard. It would be a good deal if there was no shipping and handling charges. Replacement time for each pen is about 3 months with daily use.

I purchased from this seller before and was really happy with the eyeliner because it was exactly as the photo and description. Recently, I decided to get 2 more. I was disappointed. I thought it was strange how it looked different. I just thought they decided to change the look of it. However, when I opened it and tried to use it. It wasn't even the gel one but more like a really old crayon that completely dry out. So dry that the color didn't even want to show. What happened? Quality went down this much??

This eyeliner does have a trace of glitter, which is pretty. I was worried about glitter and specs getting into my eyes, but there's no problem as the glitter is so tiny, but very pretty. Goes on smooth, nice color, but is not long lasting. This is a typical eyeliner, but enhanced with a little extra (glitter) so again, it's pretty. It just is not long lasting. You will need to put this eyeliner in your makeup bag as you will need to do touch-ups during the day, which is why I rated this as a three star product. I recently purchase "It" eyeliner and found it to be a superior eyeliner that not only stayed on an entire day but into the morning. So if you're looking for an eyeliner that needs only one application a day, try "It". I've tried tons of eyeliners, as I don't leave my bedroom in the morning without my eyes on. I would compare this eyeliner to Lancôme, which again needs touch-ups. The glitter is what makes this eyeliner.

I love this eyeyliner. I've had problems in the past with eyeliner somehow creeping its way underneath my eye leaving black smudges. This is the only eyeliner that does not do that! Also, I am astonished that it stays on all day. The only small drawback is some applications will leave you with little pieces of glitter on your cheeks or eye which sometimes bugs me but no one else probably notices them. Even though it's waterproof, it can be gently removed. I personally use vaseline to take off my eye makeup. Works like charm.

I love this teal eyeliner & have used it for years !