Butter Gloss, Non-Sticky Lip Gloss - Orangesicle (Orange)

I’m absolutely in love with the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Butter Gloss in Fortune Cookie (True Nude)! The color is perfect—it’s a beautiful nude that matches my skin tone so well and complements my makeup look every time. I also adore the butter-soft feel it gives my lips; it’s so smooth and comfortable without being sticky. The shine and gloss it adds are just the right amount of glam, making my lips look full and luscious. The size is super convenient too—small enough to carry with me everywhere, and I love that it doesn’t have any weird smell like some other glosses. This has definitely become one of my go-to products and a must-have for my makeup routine. I will definitely keep repurchasing!

This color is perfect. Creamy, shimmery and goes well with a lot of clothes I wear in the fall. I ended up getting another because it was running out so fast. Not sticky, just creamy and stays a decent amount of time on lips.

I wasn’t expecting to love this lip gloss as much as I do, but wow. The color is gorgeous without being loud, and it gives that perfect glossy finish that makes you feel a little extra put-together even on a tired day. It’s smooth, not sticky (major win), and somehow lasts through half a coffee without totally disappearing. The packaging is pretty, the applicator is actually nice to use, and it just feels… elevated. I’ve tried a lot of glosses, but this one’s officially in the “always in my bag” category. Highly recommend.

This product has a nice non sticky feeling. The color is nice but a little more hot pink than I was expecting. Second photo shows wear after 3 hours, so pigment lasts at least that long. My lips do not feel tacky or dry after it wears off. I would recommend for the price and quality feel.

my absolute favorite. so pretty and so good with my lip combos, gives shine and to me doesn’t dry fast cause i layer a clear gloss on top of my lip combos. smells really good too.

Beautiful color (Marshmallow/muted lilac). Product is shiny and moisturizing. This butter gloss appears to plump, even though that's not how it's advertised. It stays on nicely. Its just slightly sticky as most glosses are, but much less sticky than anything else I have tried. For the price, product lasts longer than a lot of glosses, however, when it gets low the wand does not reach to the bottom to get all of the gloss out. I use a longer cotton swab to reach the remainder of the gloss!

As a deep winter, pale olive girly, it's been hard to find something that gives "nude" . Madeline is the perfect color. Please never stop making it. I will buy it forever. I've tried another darker color before from this butter gloss line and I love that it leaves a stain on my lips and I'm hoping the same for Madeline. This will be my daily to-go color. Again, I will cry if you ever discontinue this color, please never do that.thx.

I really like the color of this butter gloss — it’s flattering and looks especially nice on lighter skin tones. It gives a pretty pop of color while also adding a shiny, glossy finish. The gloss glides on easily and feels smooth when first applied, and it’s definitely buildable if you want a bit more color payoff. That said, the biggest downside for me is how sticky it is. And I mean very sticky. If you get it on your hands, it sticks to everything, which can be pretty aggravating. That stickiness also makes it less comfortable to wear for long periods, especially if your hair touches your lips. Despite that, the gloss does what it’s supposed to do — it adds shine and color, and it looks great once on. I just wish the formula were less tacky, because otherwise it would be a favorite. Overall: beautiful color and shine, easy to apply, but the heavy stickiness holds it back. If you don’t mind a very sticky gloss, you’ll probably enjoy this one.