Mally Beauty – Evercolor Starlight Waterproof Eyeliner – Smudge-Proof, Longwear, Creamy Gel – Sailor Shade – 0.04 Ounce – MY.2046

I used to buy this eyeliner from QVC and thought it was the best. However this one is not really that good. Ended up with raccoon eyes only a short time after using vs the old version that was truly bulletproof. I am not sure if they changed the formula or what happened but I am less than thrilled with the current quality. I may return and will not recommend this product.

I've tried dozens of eyeliners, and this has everything I've been looking for. It glides on easily over creases, doesn't dry out, and stays put all day — even when it's hot outside and I'm sweating bullets. This will be my new go-to product.

I have tried so many eye liners but having more mature eyes. My liner always ended up smudged on the very top of my lids after a few hours. I was skeptical but after watching mally videos I decided to take the chance and let me tell you! This does everything she says it does. Awesome product. Didnt budge from were I put it until K washed it off. It even stayed inside the waterline as well. Wish Amazon had more colors available but I will definitely be going to Mallys website to get more. (Same price btw).

I got the milk chocolate shade and it's a nice color for a redhead. I would not call this waterproof or smudge-proof however. It smudges and/or disappears from the lower lash line by the end of the work day and from the waterline within an hour. It's a soft pencil so it's difficult to make a fine line; even if you sharpen it well, it doesn't hold a point long. It does wash off easily, though. I'm not sorry I bought, but it's certainly not what I hoped.

I have used her eye colors before and it stays on until you take it off. I did a no no and went to sleep in my eye make-up and it was still in place the next morning. This stays on wish there were more colors would not use any other eye shadow.

I have oily skin, so it is difficult to find products that don’t smear. Unfortunately this product was no different. It smeared and gave me raccoon eyes. I threw away almost the entire pencil.

I've bought this eyeliner quite a few times so I do like it. It's very pigmented and glides on easily. The only thing I found is that if I don't use a primer it tends to disappear quickly. But if I use a good primer or good layer of powder it lasts much longer.

This color is a mid tone warm brown.Pros: easy to apply to waterline and for tightlining, lasts and doesn’t smear, blends well, applies smoothly.Cons: difficult to sharpen, needs to be sharpened daily, color is redder than I rememberBottom line: Mally makes gorgeous products and these liners are no exception. The sharpening issue, however means I won’t repurchase.