Taffy Shop Create a 7-ounce bag of Assorted Saltwater Taffy-Choose up to 2 Flavors of Gourmet Salt Water Taffy's (World's Best Taffy)

I was looking for some specific flavors for a friend's birthday and The Taffy Shop had them. I love that you can create a bag with two flavors of your own choice. It made a perfect gift!The bag came with a little sample pack of assorted flavors that I tried. Now, I like taffy fine, but wasn't a big fan. Turns out, this stuff is so good I got addicted to it! Some pieces were hard at first, but quickly softened after sucking on them. Others were soft from the start. All were creamy and delicious!To top it all off, The Taffy Shop has amazing customer service. I had a problem with my order and they went above and beyond my expectations. I will definitely be ordering from them again!

Super good taffy. They have more flavors than you can imagine. It’s very fresh and not sticky or gooey. The flavors I got are really tasty! Better than the Atlantic City Boardwalk!

The wrong package arrived- seller was very supportive and helpful. The proper bag mix is being sent.These bite size taffy's are soft and flavorful. Can't wait to receive "my mix"

My husband and I are addicted! I like the chocolate whip and Keylime. my husband’s favorite is the frosted root beer and the Keylime. So good!

Absolutely flavorful

I ordered the tigers blood and the banana. The banana was good, but the tigers blood was gross. It's tasted like they mixed coconut and the Neapolitan together. My husband and daughter didn't like it either. And you get a very small amount for the price you pay.

Expensive but yummy

Arrived quickly. But...something is different about the taffy. My peppermint was not as strong as usual. what happened? I have been buying for 2 years with this company. Also, the espresso chocolate tasted off...kind of like drinking coffee with eggnog. It may be my taste buds and not the taffy recipe i was expecting. Please bring back regular Very Vanilla. I do not use or eat artificial sweeteners.