Grumpy Butcher 6 Steaks Sampler Set Gift Box: 2 Large Filet Mignons & 4 New York Strip Steaks - Prime Steakhouse Quality - Gourmet Food Gifts Packages Specials Carne Asada

Great tast and tender

Alright, bud. Here's a review from one butcher to another. I don't usually order steaks online since I run my own butcher shop here in New York and can get any kind of meat. But I was flying to see a old buddy and didn't want to risk checking my own meat with two connecting flights. I'll skip the basics like trim, gristle, connective tissue, and the right amount of marbling for each cut. If your steaks had any issues like this, I’d have given you one star and wouldn't bother with this review. So, I got filet mignons New York strips and ribeye steaks. Here's the rundown. NY strip steaks are A-. Very good overall, black angus, aged about 3 weeks. Didn't like that they were packed 4 in a pack. Not a big deal, but not ideal. Filet mignons gets A from me. Prime beef, perfect shape center cut from beef tendeloin, good size, even for a Texan. Aged at least 2-3 weeks, right? Ribeyes were REALLY good and deserve an A+. Superb black angus, medium to bold flavor, perfect for grilling.Good work, man. I’ll probably order your sous vide wagyu ribs. We don't have them.

Received as a gift and, in turn, send them as a gift. The best steaks we’ve ever had and, trust me, we’ve eaten a lot of steaks. Great value as well.

Ordered these steaks for our Christmas dinner and was super impressed with how quickly they arrived! I placed the order on a Wednesday, and they were here by Friday, so faster than I expected! They were packed perfectly in a cooler box, so there was no worry about spoilage. The steaks cooked beautifully on the grill, tender and juicy with a fantastic char. My guests were amazed. I will definitely order from Grumpy Butcher again!

I purchased the 2 NY strip and 2 ribeye bundle. They all looked amazing and I couldn't wait to grill them. Well the strip steak had a lot of fat and gristle; way too much for this price point and quality. Once I dissected the bad stuff out I had roughly 3/4 of the steak left. There were some good bites but overall very disappointing. The ribeye I had today was even worse with more gristle/fat. These steaks are definitely substandard and not worth the price and I feel ripped off. I would never buy from this place again. The name of the company should not be grumpy butcher but grumpy customers.

I’m not a great cook, but even I managed to make these steaks taste incredible! A quick sear on each side and a finish in the oven was all it took. They were tender, juicy and bursting with flavor, especially the minions.

Ordered this steak set as a part of Mother’s Day gift dinner for my wife, with the kids coming over to celebrate. I cooked the whole dinner myself - sides, salads, steaks for the rest of us and her favorite fish, since she’s never been much of a meat eater. But after one bite of my steak, she quietly slid her plate over and said, “Trade me?” I ended up with the fish, and she finished every bit of my steak. Ha-ha... We’ve been married a long time, but moments like that still make me smile.

Was a gift and receiver considered the meat not well marbled and not as good as they could buy at grocery