MAYBELLINE Unstoppable Waterproof Mechanical Blue Eyeliner Pencil, Easy to Apply, Smooth Glide, Up to 24 Hour Wear, Sapphire, Pack of 2

Just the right amount of softness to apply along the eyelash line without trauma to eyelid. I use one shade lighter than my eyelash color to avoid looking like a street performer. A lighter line looks more natural. Was pleased with how long the line was maintained, but did require makeup remover to remove residual after soap and water washing. Not having to sharpen it was a plus. Cannot yet comment on longevity.

Nice product goes on smoothly without pulling the eyelid. Well done

Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner is hands down my favorite! I've been using it for years, and it never disappoints. It goes on smoothly, stays in place without smudging, and lasts all day long. Perfect for a long-lasting, flawless look. Highly recommend!

I love this product.. Beautiful color that brings out my blue eyes. Easy to apply. Well priced.I only wish it would stay on a bit longer. I find I need to apply it more than once a day to keep the effect I want.

I love this eye liner. It's soft enough that it goes on without pulling and it stays put all day long. I love this color. It's a bit brighter and lighter than the typical brown eye liners. Very good value for the money.

This is the only eyeliner I can use that does not irritate my eyes, and, unfortunately it is becoming harder and harder to find. I really like that it stays on all day without wandering down my cheek or making eye goobies . And probably part of the reason it is hard to find is that I like the sapphire color because I have kind of pale eyes and the deep blue is not as stark as the black color nor as blah as the brown. I don't think subtle is as popular as it used to be.

My go to eyeliner! Lasts all day. Good value for the money.

I love the color. This is the second time I have purchased. Will not again, it breaks off with use. Most ends up in the garbage.