JOAHMake Her Gel-ous Gel Eyeliner with Self-Sharpening Pencil, Waterproof & Long-Lasting Intense Color Definition & Finish, Creamy No-Tug Formula - Espresso

Good product worth the price. Waterproof and stays on for hours

This pencil is easy to use, makes a clean line and looks great. It lasts for a long time and is easy to be smoothed for a softer line.

I like to smudge my eyeliner, then return with a soft black line near my eyelash- and this product is perfect for this application. Love it - and receive it regularly with a subscription!

Says it comes with a sharpener. I ordered more than one of these and none of them came with a sharpener. Ever though it's in the description and printed on the box. Would love to have a sharpener.

I like JOAH products. I especially like that every JOAH product I've purchased in stores and online has come with a great tamper proof seal.I bought this eyeliner in Black but it does not glide on. It is much too dry for me to use on my eyelid. I tried to make it work by using a smudger to smooth it out but that did not work. I don't like tugging at my eye area.I like the tip though, so I tried to use it on my eyebrows but it's too dark for that.

I was super excited to try this. I love this color, especially with my brown eyes. But, mine arrived with the cap off, so there was nothing “gel” about it. Idk if I got a returned one or not, bc the tape seal was already broken on the box. It feels like a dried out crayon with sand in it.Sucks. I really wanted to love this.

Nice glide and hangs on all day

This liner is so easy to use. I use an eye primer and powder shadow. This liner glides on easy and lasts until I wash it off and the brown color is perfect. Not to dark or light.